Self's punishment
Tuesday, November 29, 2005
I found myself finishing a book I was reading and needing to read something else, whilst being out for the day.
Having read 'The reader' and 'Acts of love' by Bernard Schlink, I had my eye on Self's punishment, but it didn't look sufficiently appealing to purchase.
I was totally enchanted with 'The reader', slightly less so with 'Acts of love', which was a compilation of short stories, one of them rather magic, but the rest heavy and not that enticing.
But I love the way he writes. His style is simple yet beautiful and cuts just right. It concerned me that he co wrote this book with someone else and that it is a detective mystery but something in me wanted to stay loyal to him and I really had to make a snappy decision so I purchased it.
The book itself is made up of a rather corny story with a historical twist. Like 'The reader', it concerns the second World War but it is about the private detective that is in his sixties, has lost a wife and has a lonesome life. Having been engaged in an investigation at the big chemical plant by his ex brother in law and a friend, he finds a culprit soon but there are implications...
Along the way he meets two women...one he meets in the course of his investigation and she intrigues him, there is something about her that he can't figure out. She is called Judith. Throughout the book there is this mood between them, like they found each other but it will never be. And the other he meets in the bar, called Brigitte, that just seems to be a nice person in the right place.
I couldn't care less about the mystery, what I love about Schlink is the way he weaves the relationships of his characters. There is always some deep underlying sadness, some clandestine understanding between two people and there is the fact that things almost never work out how you think they should in a book.
There was a poignant bit in the book, where him and Judith have a conversation in the car and she confronts him about knowing he is interested in her and yet is not making a move and this strips him of all of his defences and yet there is nowhere for him to go and nowhere to hide and he has to deal with her. And this creates this magic yet rather heavy,sad moment that, in my opinion, makes the book what it is.
"What had actually humiliated me? Judith had only hit me around the head with what I'd felt myself in recent months: the lack of clarity in my feelings towards her. But she'd done it so unkindly by quoting myself back at me that I felt exposed and skewered. I told her so near Zofingen.
She let her knitting sink to her lap and stared out in front of her at the road for a long while.
'When I was an executive assistant I so often encountered men who wanted something from me, but didn't put themselves on the line. They'd like to have something going with me, but at the same time they'd pretend they didn't. They'd arrange things so they could immediately retreat without getting really involved.
It seemed to me that was the lie of the land with you, as well. You make the first move, but perhaps it isn't really one, a gesture that costs you nothing and has no risk attached.'"
I haven't finished it yet, I am still reading through but I wanted to make this impressions real now before they change with the ending.
It makes me utterly melancholic because I know Judith will lose the battle, things that are unspoken and deep and complicated never happen, they just don't.
Because of their intensity and magnitude, people are never willing to risk it and come out without the defence army.
And yet I guess, everyone yearns to be able to go out without an army.
It also makes me nostalgic because I know of moments like this, unsaid, where you pretend everything is breezy and fine, just as you like it and it isn't and all along you yearn to just come as you are, wearing no crinoline, hair down...
But it rarely happens in life because it depends on two people and not just one, making moves towards each other and the dance, as delicate as it is, stands no chance against the ease with which one can dance drunk at a bad Christmas party.
But those, although safe, never make it to Royal Albert Hall or even close.


























